SafeHome.org may receive compensation from some providers listed on this page. Learn More
We may receive compensation from some providers listed on this page. Learn More
Should you get a home security system with Protection 1 or cut out the middleman and sign up with ADT?
Editor’s Note: This is an archived review. ADT acquired Protection 1 in May 2016, after which the latter began selling ADT equipment. Even today, buying from Protection 1’s website sends you to ADT’s packages. Since we believe home security shouldn’t be complicated, we advise skipping the middleman, Protection 1, and buying straight from ADT. Before you do, take a look at our ADT hands-on review.
Protection 1 doesn’t sell its own equipment anymore, and even at its best it wasn’t a top-tier security system. Its pricing was competitive but often ran above industry averages. It offered early home automation features and advanced equipment, yet it trailed the leading home automation security systems such as ADT and Vivint.
From our experience evaluating its legacy systems, Protection 1’s standout innovation was its triple-redundancy monitoring. That routed alerts to backup centers if a primary station went offline. It was forward-thinking at the time. Today, ADT operates six fully redundant monitoring centers in the U.S., setting a higher bar for reliability and response times.
Home security looks very different now that Protection 1 is part of ADT. To make sense of today’s options, start with our home security buyer’s guide and our current ranking of the best home security systems that we confidently recommend this year.
The Protection 1 review you’re about to read (if you really want to) is from when we tested the last security system they released in late 2016 and into early 2017.
Check out more recommendations from the SafeHome team:
Protection 1 sold wireless home security packages built on triple-redundancy monitoring. Sensors around your home reported activity and potential threats, and when an alarm triggered, the signal went straight to a Protection 1 monitoring center. If severe weather or a power outage knocked that center offline, the signal automatically rerouted to another one, so protection never lapsed. A trained Protection 1 employee at the center immediately tried calling you to check for a false alarm, then judged whether to contact emergency responders like police, fire, or EMS.
All equipment was professionally installed and maintained by licensed technicians who passed background checks and completed intensive training before entering homes. When you called for support, a real person picked up instead of an automated system. Unlike most security companies at the time, they aimed to resolve service calls within a single day, which was impressive for the era.
The best features of this system include:
In the past, Protection 1 focused on helping customers save on energy bills and homeowners’ insurance instead of providing big deals. ADT carries that forward with the Nest smart thermostat and most homeowner’s insurers offer discounts if you have an ADT system with active monitoring. However, they also offer regular deals that sometimes even include free security cameras.
Just like Protection 1 used to, ADT also offers military discounts. ADT even provides free home evaluations where a specialist will recommend a customized system to fit your needs and budget.
Insider Tips: Do you already have a security system? If you give ADT a call and tell them your situation, they may offer to buy out your current security system contract allowing you to switch to ADT without paying a cancellation fee.
.
| Secure | Secure+ | Smart Control | Video |
|---|---|---|---|
| 34.99/mo | 44.99/mo | 49.99/mo | 54.99/mo |
| + $99 Upfront Costs* | + $99 Upfront Costs* | + $99 Upfront Costs* | + $99 Upfront Costs* |
| Learn About ADT | Learn About ADT | Learn About ADT | Learn About ADT |
| Services | Services | Services | Services |
| 24/7 Monitoring | 24/7 Monitoring | 24/7 Monitoring | Video Surveillance |
| Intrusion Protection | Intrusion Protection | Intrusion Protection | 24/7 Monitoring |
| Environmental & Life Safety | Environmental & Life Safety | Environmental & Life Safety | Intrusion Protection |
| Monitored Fire & Carbon Monoxide Protection | Monitored Fire & Carbon Monoxide Protection | Monitored Fire & Carbon Monoxide Protection | Environmental & Life Safety |
| Cellular Communication | Cellular Communication | Monitored Fire & Carbon Monoxide Protection | |
| 2-Way Voice | 2-Way Voice | Cellular Communication | |
| Camera Integrated Motion Detector | 2-Way Voice | ||
| Web & Mobile Control | Camera Integrated Motion Detector | ||
| Energy & Home Automation | Web & Mobile Control | ||
| Energy & Home Automation | |||
| Equipment | Equipment | Equipment | Equipment |
| Intrusion protection keypad | Intrusion Protection Keypad | Intrusion Protection Keypad | Intrusion Protection Keypad |
| 3 Door and Window Sensors | 3 Door and Window Sensors | 3 Door and Window Sensors | Indoor, Night-vision Security Camera |
| Motion Detector | Motion Detector | Motion Detector | 3-Door and Window Sensors |
| Smoke Alarm | Smoke Alarm | Smoke Alarm | Motion Detector |
| Carbon Monoxide Alarm | Carbon Monoxide Alarm | Carbon Monoxide Alarm | Smoke Alarm |
| Panic Button | Panic Button | Panic Button | Carbon Monoxide Alarm |
| Environmental Alarm | Environmental Alarm | Environmental Alarm | Panic Button |
| Keychain Remote | Keychain Remote | Keychain Remote | Environmental Alarm |
| Image Motion Sensor | Keychain Remote | ||
| Image Motion Sensor | |||
| Options | Options | Options | Options |
| Video Surveillance | |||
How does your home measure up when it comes to security? Take this quiz to see how you score, and get recommendations to protect your home.
Banks, jewelry stores, medical centers, and high-profile clients across the country trusted Protection 1, a full-service security company. It held an A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau, kept a strong customer satisfaction record, and served approximately 2 million customers from its Chicago, Illinois headquarters. Then, in May 2016, it merged with ADT, America’s largest provider of hardwired and wireless home security equipment and monitoring. That merger has shaped how ADT delivers professionally installed security nationwide ever since.
MOBILE ALERTS |
With Protection 1’s Smart Control package, you can program your system to send you mobile alerts for any activity or alarms. |
24/7 MONITORING |
All residential security systems are monitored 24/7 at Protection 1 central monitoring centers. Sensors throughout your home communicate activity and potential threats. If an alarm is triggered, the signal routes directly to a Protection 1 monitoring center. |
WIRELESS EQUIPMENT |
Protection 1 uses wireless equipment, so you don't need a landline. You also won’t need to worry about extra wires and cables that potential burglars can snip. |
SURVEILLANCE CAMERAS |
Motion sensors from Protection 1 come equipped with cameras that take a color picture if unexpected movements occur inside your home. The system can text you the photo, email it to you, or you can check in on the camera with your smartphone. |
PRO INSTALLATION |
All security equipment is installed by certified security technicians who must pass rigorous training and background checks. |
SMART HOME OPTIONS |
Protection 1's Smart Control package allows you to control your home through automated thermostats, lighting, locks, and appliances. |
DISASTER PROTECTION |
Protection 1 protects against disasters by monitoring for extreme temperatures and flooding. |
REMOTE CONTROL |
Protection 1 allows you to remotely control with your phone or computer anything that you can control from the keypad in your home. You can arm or disarm your system and control any automated devices. |
POWER OUTAGE PROTECTION |
If the security center monitoring your home loses power, Protection 1 automatically routes your security monitoring to another center without interruption. |
MEDICAL ALERTS |
A remote panic button can alert the Protection 1 monitoring center of a medical emergency. |
Protection 1 gave homeowners a lot, but it was never a top-rated system like SimpliSafe. Still, it delivered a quality, professionally installed security system with 24/7 monitoring. Pricing sat on the higher end, especially for video surveillance or advanced smart home features, but it remained a solid, dependable way to keep your home protected.
The $99 upfront cost was a real highlight, because it got you a respectable amount of equipment right away. Monthly monitoring, however, started at around $35, which adds up fast under a long-term contract. Not a fan of recurring monthly fees? See our list of the best no monthly fee home security systems of 2026.