Medical Guardian and LifeStation systems are both rated as highly effective for the level of service and types of features that are offered. Both companies offer at home and mobile protection using cellular and GPS connectivity.
Overview: Medical Guardian vs LifeStation
Medical Guardian and LifeStation systems offer devices that are capable of notifying both emergency personnel and family members in the event that an accident occurs. Both include fall detection with their higher level packages and a wide variety of medical devices to meet most needs.
- Both companies offer waterproof devices
- 24/7 professional monitoring services are offered by both systems
- Medical Guardian has a range of 1300 feet for the home package
- LifeStation has a range of 1000 feet in and around the home
- LifeStation has upfront fees for equipment
Similarities: LifeStation vs Medical Guardian
Both Medical Guardian and LifeStation offer the user the capability of notifying emergency personnel and family members if an accident occurs. Each company offers state of the art technology that runs operates through the use of cellular service and GPS coordinates.
- No contracts are required by either company
- Neither company requires cancellation fees if you discontinue service
- Both systems are easily installed by the customer
- 24/7 professional monitoring services are offered by each system
- Lifetime warranties are included with each medical alert device
Differences: LifeStation vs Medical Guardian
The biggest differences between Medical Guardian and LifeStation is the level of technology in the pendants and other medical devices. Medical Guardian's pendants offer limited two-way communication, while LifeStation's pendants don't have the capability for voice communication.
- Medical Guardian offers a Price Lock Guarantee
- LifeStation offers a 30-day money back guarantee
- Medical Guardian requires a 90-day service agreement instead of a contract
- Medical Guardian does not charge for the equipment or require an activation fee
Medical Guardian offers both at home protection (1300 feet) as well as mobile service with an unlimited range. They offer a wide selection of devices that includes the traditional pendant, a bracelet option, and clip-on devices that attach securely to belts or other straps. Fall protection is included with the more expensive packages.
LifeStation has its own monitoring center staffed with CSAA-certified specialists. The base unit allows for two-way communication with the monitoring center. LifeStation also includes an “at home” range of 1000 feet and mobile services that allow for unlimited travel. Fall detection can be included with any package for $10-15 extra per month.
Instead of requiring subscribers to sign on with a lengthy contract, Medical Guardian only requires a 90-day service agreement. They also offer a price lock guarantee.
LifeStation does not require a long-term contract or charge cancellation fees.
Medical Guardian has several packages to choose from, starting with the Classic Guardian which costs $29.95 a month. The Home Guardian package costs $34.95 a month and the Active Guardian starts at $49.95. Medical Guardian's Mobile Guardian package is priced at $39.95 a month. There are no shipping or activation fees and no cost for the equipment.
LifeStation plans are paid on a monthly basis. The In-Home Landline package costs $19.95/monthly. The In-Home Wireless packages are $26.95/monthly. The Mobile with GPS package costs are $24.95/monthly.
Medical Guardian includes a base unit and your choice of a pendant, bracelet, or clip-on device. Devices offer limited, two-way communication. Equipment is waterproof and can be worn in the shower. Lockboxes are also offered.
With LifeStation, you receive a base unit and a choice of several different devices. They offer waterproof pendants and wristbands, as well as clip-on devices for belts. You can also choose a lockbox, mobile emergency button, and bathroom/hallway buttons for additional protection.
Both companies provide instructions for self-installation.
Medical Guardian requires a landline for the base unit, but all of the other devices are supported by cellular service. 24/7 connectivity allows for both emergency response teams as well as individuals on the individual's contact list to be notified by either text or phone.
LifeStation offers its own in-house 24/7 monitoring service. Devices are supported by cellular service. Staff at the monitoring center will notify emergency response teams, as well as send texts to or call those on the individual's call list.
Summary: Medical Guardian vs LifeStation
Medical Guardian is a great choice for individuals who are extremely active and want a wider range in terms of distance. The prices are affordable for the level of services offered.
LifeStation is a good choice if you don't mind spending more for the level of service they offer. They do offer the convenience of pre-paying for the first nine months so you don't have to worry about a bill for the first few months.