Best Home Insurance for California Homeowners in 2023

Here are our top three picks for home insurers in the Golden State.

Page Hero Image

SecureScore™: 9.4/10

Lemonade is quickly becoming one of our favorite homeowners insurance providers. Fast settlements, transparent pricing, great customer service – they check all the boxes California homeowners need.

View Packages

State Farm
SecureScore™: 9.3/10

A solid choice for Californians looking to get the best ROI on their policy, State Farm offers excellent protections, insurance bundles, and customer service.

SecureScore™: 9.1/10

Another well-respected name in home insurance, Nationwide offers comprehensive coverage across California and one of the best online quote tools we’ve seen.

Home insurance is the same for everyone, right? At its most basic, yes. Your home insurance policy is there, like a home security system you trust, to protect you from catastrophic dangers that can turn your life upside down in a flash. Freak weather. Freak accidents. Even thieves. Or to put it another way: home insurance is home security.

But how our policies protect us varies considerably. In California, you may be looking for an insurance provider that gives solid green discounts. Or you could be on the hunt for a company that gives great rates when you bundle home and auto insurance together. For many Golden Staters, however, the question of the hour is: Am I covered for wildfires?

Like I said, plenty of personal situations to consider — and plenty of companies touting solutions. To give you an idea of your best options in California, we’ve studied all the top plans on the market and chosen three we believe offer the best protection (and value) for California homeowners today.

Did You Know: Wildfires may be on the rise in California, but burglary has actually come down a bit in the past few years — maybe because so many CA residents have turned to these top home security cameras to keep the bad guys off their property.

Best Homeowners Insurance in California in 2023

  • Lemonade - If there was an award for Best New Insurer, Lemonade would be our pick, hands down. They offer fair and transparent pricing, their website and app are both extremely well designed, and their coverages are expansive. If you’re looking for a reasonably priced policy that protects everything you need, Lemonade might be for you.
  • State Farm - If Lemonade is the new kid on the block, State Farm is the old hand. With nearly a century of experience, State Farm has made a name for itself as a provider that really gives you a lot of bang for the buck. We don’t want to say they’re cheap — that implies poor quality. What they are is an affordable provider with great customer service and coverages.
  • Nationwide - Another insurer with nearly a century’s worth of experience, Nationwide isn’t the cheapest provider out there, but you certainly see where the money is going. With one of the best customer service reputations out there, Nationwide is another top option for California residents.
  • 1. Lemonade - Best Overall Coverage for California Homeowners

    SecureScore™ 9.4
    Customer Service
    Online Quote

    This six-year-old company is virtually brand new as far as insurers go, but Lemonade is looking to demystify homeowners insurance and make purchasing a policy — dare we say — fun.

    • Low rates
    • Fast, fun AI quote builder
    • Transparent policies
    • Excellent digital experience
    • Instant claims payments via the Lemonade app
    • Giveback program invests unused claims in charities
    • Can’t replace belongings at cost
    • Only available in 22 states (so far)
    • Only in business for six years

    When you’re shopping for a homeowners insurance policy, a lot of these websites and apps may feel a little … dated. We guess that makes sense, given that some of the top insurers in the country have been around for a century or more.

    But just because a website isn’t sleek and modern, that doesn’t mean your service will suffer or the product is subpar. That said, in our countless hours of exploring homeowners insurance and reviewing providers, we’ve found that this stuffiness can translate to their overall approach.

    Not so with Lemonade, our top pick for California homeowners.

    Lemonade's extra protections

    Lemonade’s extra protections

    When we reviewed Lemonade, we were immediately impressed by their fresh approach to homeowners insurance. Their website is intuitive, everything is explained in easy-to-understand language, and their AI-based quote-building tool named Maya is actually pretty fun to work with.

    But does this digital-first approach amount to just a pretty face? Not at all. Lemonade offers the same powerful core protections as its older counterparts with some interesting add-on coverages, including:

    • Portable electronics coverage
    • Appliance breakdown
    • Buried utility protections
    • Water backup
    • Valuables

    Now we didn’t really like that their list of discounts was relatively short, but as you’ll see on our guide to Lemonade’s costs and plans, their premiums don’t require discounts to be affordable. We also didn’t really like that they’re currently available only in 22 states, but the good news is that California is included on that list. When you’re shopping around for the best home insurance policy, we certainly recommend giving Lemonade a look.

  • 2. State Farm - Most Affordable Coverage for Californians

    SecureScore™ 9.3
    Customer Service
    Online Quote

    One of the most well-known names in the home insurance industry, State Farm offers some of the most affordable coverages available. But don’t let the price tag fool you — you’re purchasing one of the most comprehensive policies available.

    • Heavy discounts on multi-product bundles
    • Replacement cost value possessions coverage
    • Fast online quotes and claims
    • 19,000 agents nationwide
    • Top-rated for customer satisfaction
    • Free three-year Ting subscription
    • Can’t purchase bundles online
    • Fewer discounts than some close competitors
    • Not available in Massachusetts or Rhode Island

    There are two big takeaways when it comes to State Farm’s homeowners insurance: its total-home-coverage nature and its affordable pricing.

    Generally speaking, when you pay less for something, you get less. That’s a universal concept, but it doesn’t hold true for State Farm. Although their policies tend to cost less than the average, we found in our State Farm review that their protections are generally stronger — even than those of some of their more expensive competitors.

    While their prices aren’t rock bottom, our research shows they consistently perform better than their competitors in terms of premium affordability. And the coverage does not suffer for it.

    State Farm makes customizing your policy easy

    State Farm makes customizing your policy easy

    State Farm’s standard policies include items like business property insurance, a building ordinance rider, and other powerful protections that other providers offer only as add-ons. And State Farm’s add-ons really put them above the competition. Identity restoration, computer protection, and, yes, earthquake coverage.

    While you’ll still need to shop around for the right protections and the right prices for your specific situation, we’re pretty confident in saying that State Farm is very likely to end up on your shortlist.

  • 3. Nationwide - Best Unique Coverages for Californians

    SecureScore™ 9.1
    Customer Service
    Online Quote

    Nationwide is a trusted name in the home insurance industry, offering exceptional coverage and customer service, although you might end up paying a little extra for it.

    • A+ Better Business Bureau rating
    • Inexpensive policies
    • Quick online quotes
    • Mobile claims filing and bill payment
    • Inflation protection is standard
    • Plenty of great perks, such as credit card insurance
    • Replacing possessions at cost takes time
    • Can’t cancel policies online
    • Not available everywhere

    Nationwide is one of those workhorse insurance providers that you can tell is really looking out for its customers. They consistently have some of the best customer service ratings in the industry, and they offer standard protections that others don’t.

    One of our favorites is that your policy is automatically tied to inflation. That means if you insure your home for $300,000, and it’s worth $500,000 by the time you make a major claim, you’re not on the hook for the difference. That protection comes standard, as does their credit card fraud protection, but what about their add-ons?

    The list is pretty long. More on that in our Nationwide home insurance analysis, but some of our favorites include:

    • Brand-new belongings
    • Better roof replacement
    • Valuables replaced at cost

    Pretty good stuff. Now for the not so good. While Nationwide is by no means expensive, their costs do tend to run a bit higher than those of their competitors. We’ve got more specifics in our guide to Nationwide’s prices, but keep in mind that they aren’t the cheapest provider. When you consider what you’re getting, though, we say the price is more than reasonable.

    Nationwide has been poviding insurance for nearly a century

    Nationwide has been poviding insurance for nearly a century

    All right, we hope this list helps you streamline your selection process while shopping around for homeowners insurance. But for a deeper dive, here are a few more items for you to consider.

What Is Homeowners Insurance, and What Does it Cover?

In all but a few very unique situations, you’re required to carry homeowners insurance to secure a mortgage. While that might seem like a frustrating box to check in the litany of boxes you’re checking while purchasing a home, you really should take the time to research homeowners insurance — like you’re doing now — to purchase the policy that fits your situation and budget best.

FYI: We recommend getting quotes from at least five different providers. Compare them on the coverages offered, not just the premium price. Cheaper isn’t always better!

At the most basic level, a homeowners insurance policy makes sure you’re not on the hook to cover the remainder of your mortgage should something catastrophic happen. However, modern policies are a lot more nuanced than that; they actually protect you from a whole lot more than running out of cash during a major home repair.

The most common policies — called HO-3 policies — cover six things:

  • The dwelling: The home itself
  • Other structures: A shed, a fence, a detached garage
  • Personal possessions: Most of the possessions inside your home, with a few exceptions
  • Personal liability: Covers you if someone is injured on your property and decides to sue
  • Medical liability: Covers the medical costs of someone injured on your property
  • Loss of use: If your home is severely damaged, covers your living expenses while it’s being repaired

Keep in mind that some insurance providers will call these protections different things and the limitations of those coverages will depend on your provider and how much you’re willing to pay for your premium. There are a few California-specific considerations to discuss when it comes to homeowners insurance, though. What about wildfires?

Are Wildfires Covered by My Homeowners Insurance?

The short answer is yes. A standard homeowners insurance policy should protect you from damage caused by a wildfire. However, as wildfires continue to increase in frequency and severity, some insurers are trying to shield themselves from risk by excluding them from their policies and selling wildfire protection as an add-on.

As a rule of thumb, when it comes to insurance, it’s always better to be proactive than reactive. Ask your insurer if your home will be protected in the event of a wildfire, and if not, ask how much more it will cost. Homeowners insurance is an investment, and a few extra dollars per month now is a whole lot better than hundreds of thousands down the road.

That said, fires are covered by a standard policy. You know what’s never covered, though, unless you explicitly ask for it? Earthquakes.

What Is Earthquake Insurance, and Do I Need It?

Here’s a sobering fact. FEMA estimates that 90 percent of the earthquakes in this country occur in California, yet only 10 percent of California residents carry earthquake insurance.

It’s difficult to say why this is. We’d say most of these folks assume earthquake damage would be covered. It makes sense, right? Your home insurance covers the cost of a new roof if a tree falls through it during a storm, so why wouldn’t it cover a crack in your foundation from an earthquake?

Pro Tip: Most big providers use partners to underwrite earthquake insurance policies, meaning you’ll have to deal with that partner when filing a claim. The good news is that they usually aren’t that expensive.

Well, we didn’t write the rules. Earth events like earthquakes and sinkholes just aren’t covered by HO-3 policies. If you want protection — and you should consider your risk as a California resident —  you’ll have to pay extra for it. Just how much depends on how threatened your home is.

Speaking of costs, exactly how much are we talking for home insurance in California? If you’ve never purchased homeowners insurance — or haven’t in a while — it’s a fair question.

How Much Does Homeowners Insurance Cost?

Generally speaking, the average homeowners insurance policy costs about $105 per month. That said, this figure can fluctuate pretty drastically depending on a variety of factors, including:

  • How much your home is worth
  • Where your home is located
  • The age of your home
  • How well your home has been maintained
  • The materials used to build your home
  • Security and safety measures installed

And so on and so forth. For an average home in California — meaning one around $600,000 located in a decent neighborhood that is not in direct peril of natural disasters — you’re probably looking at north of $100 per month.

Is it worth it? Absolutely. Your home is a huge investment, and it’s likely your most important possession. You want to take the time and do the legwork to ensure it’s insured comprehensively.

Final Thoughts

Whether you choose Lemonade, State Farm, Nationwide, or any of the other home insurance providers, just be sure that you put some protections in place. Trust us, you’ll sleep a little easier at night.

Not convinced the insurance providers on our list are right for you? No problem. Head over to our list of the 10 best homeowners insurance providers of 2023 to learn about some other great options.