Learn More About Medical Guardian

Between these two security systems, our favorite is Medical Guardian.

SecureScore™: 8.8/10

Ready to talk to a representative? Call now!

View Packages

Medical Guardian and LifeFone medical alert companies are two of the most well-rounded systems on the market. Both offer multiple packages and devices to choose from, as well as a comprehensive listing of features and services.

Overview: Medical Guardian vs LifeFone

Medical Guardian and LifeFone are well-known providers of medical alert devices. Both rate very high in many of the online reviews simply because of the number of packages/price points they offer and the technology that backs up their equipment. Both have been in business for several years and have built a solid reputation to back up their systems.

  • No long-term contracts are required
  • Both offer fall detection as part of their more advanced plans
  • Both have some type of warranty in place
  • Both systems work anywhere in the United States
  • Several plans and package options are available

Similarities: LifeFone vs Medical Guardian

Medical Guardian and LifeFone are similar in a variety of ways. Both have features that are designed to assist patients within their home as well as when they are out in public. The mobile technology used by each company allows for accurate geo-location and immediate emergency response.

  • Devices are waterproof
  • 24/7/365 professional monitoring with specially trained technicians
  • Each system offers up to a 1,300-foot range from their in-home base unit
  • Offers rapid response for emergencies that occur at home and while you're away
  • Offers landline and cellular connectivity options
  • Devices offer two-way communication

Differences: LifeFone vs Medical Guardian

The main differences between Medical Guardian and LifeFone are in their pricing, with LifeFone's being somewhat lower for similar coverage. LifeFone offers a mobile app but on the negative side, the buttons on its bracelet device are smaller than what many people are comfortable with. Medical Guardian and LifeFone both offer Family Plan options, but LifeFone offers limited free service to a spouse.

  • Buttons on LifeFone's bracelet are small
  • Medical Guardian requires a 90-day service agreement
  • LifeFone's fees are billed annually
  • LifeFone's fees are lower on certain packages
  • Medical Guardian offers a Family Plan ($79.95 monthly)


Medical Guardian's primary features include both in-home and GPS-enhanced location that allows for protection at home and out in public. Lockboxes are offered that allow emergency personnel access to the home without having to wait on family or break-in to gain access. A medical history card is also offered. Cellular and landline connectivity allows for almost immediate response times by emergency personnel.

LifeFone's mobile app can be used as a substitute for the pendant if desired. While the LifeFone's bracelet is comparable in terms of technology and capabilities, it's designed with smaller than average buttons that can be difficult to use during an emergency situatation.


Medical Guardian does not require any type of contract per se but does require a 90-day service agreement.

LifeFone does not require a contract.


Medical Guardian offers multiple packages and pricing options. The Classic Guardian package costs just less than$30 a month. The Home Guardian is next at just under $35 a month. The Active Guardian is next at slightly under $50 a month. The Mobile Guardian is also available at just under $40 a month. The Family Plan starts at just under $80 per month. There are no activation or equipment fees.

LifeFone offers two at home plans and two plans for on the go. The At Home Landline Plan costs $24.95 a month while the At Home Cellular Plan costs $30.95 a month. The At Home and On the Go Plan with Optional Fall Detection starts at $36.95 a month. The At Home and On the Go Plan that includes both Voice in Pendant and Fall Detection starts at $42.95 a month. All packages are billed monthly. There are no activation or equipment fees.


Medical Guardian's packages include a base unit, pendants, bracelets, and clip-on devices with two-way communication and optional fall detection. Fall detection is included in many of the higher priced packages. Wearable devices are waterproof. Lockboxes with medical history cards are also available.

LifeFone also offers a base unit, bracelet, and pendant with two-way communication and optional fall detection. In addition to these devices, they also offer a variety of caregiver tools, the mobile app, and fire and smoke alarms.


Neither company requires professional installation. Set up for each system is quick with easy to understand instructions.

Emergency Connections

Both companies offer emergency connectivity through both landline and cellular service. GPS-enabled geo-locators are able to identify your location and dispatch emergency personnel in a matter of minutes. Texts and/or phone calls are also placed to numbers placed on your contact list.

Summary: Medical Guardian vs LifeFone

Medical Guardian offers nationwide service and offers a comprehensive list of services and features. It's an ideal system for anyone who is willing to pay a little more for convenience and security.

LifeFone is also an excellent value. It also offers nationwide coverage and offers affordable pricing options for individuals who are on a fixed income.

Read our full review of Medical Guardian

Read our full review of LifeFone