Medical Alert and Bay Alarm Medical systems are reliable and effective. The systems are rather basic but are easy to use and offer an almost immediate response when they receive an alert. While the systems offer different features and services, they are comparable in both price and devices.
Overview: Medical Alert vs Bay Alarm Medical
Medical Alert and Bay Alarm offer both at home and away coverage. While both offer their services nationwide, Medical Alert also services Canada, the Virgin Islands, and Puerto Rice. Each company provides reliable and professional service.
- Supports multiple languages (Medical Alert – 140, Bay Alarm Medical – 170)
- Neither company requires a contract
- Fall protection is optional with certain packages
- Bay Medical Alert offers discounts for members of AAA, USAA, and AARP
- Both systems are installed by the user
Similarities: Bay Alarm Medical vs Medical Alert
Both Medical Alert and Bay Alarm Medical are no frill systems that don't require professional installation or a long-term contract. They offer similar devices with many of the same features. Call centers from each company will notify family members as well as dispatch emergency personnel if an alarm is triggered.
- 24-hour a day service, 365 days a year
- Both offer waterproof pendants
- Systems are easy to set up with neither requiring a visit from a professional technician
- Both companies require a 90-day service agreement
- Both offer landline and cellular options
Differences: Bay Alarm Medical vs Medical Alert
Medical Alert and Bay Alarm are similar in price and services but each is slightly different in terms of features and devices. This especially true in terms of fall detection with Bay Alarm only offering it in their “at-home” packages and Medical Alert narrowing the option to only select “at-home” packages.
- Medical Alert is associated with both CVS and Connect America
- Bay Alert offers a two-week trial period
- Medical Alert offers waterproof pendants and wristband devices
- Bay Alert doesn't offer fall protection with their mobile packages
- Bay Alert doesn't offer refunds on prepaid subscriptions
Medical Alert's features include GPS-enabled wristbands and pendants. Two-way communication is provided through the base unit. Fall detection is offered as an optional feature. Medical Alert's call centers provide 24-hour response for any type of medical emergency.
Bay Alarm Medical supports over 170 languages. The pendant provided by Bay Alarm is waterproof and very durable. Fall detection is available for “at-home” packages but not for the mobile packages. GPS tracking is supported by T-Mobile or AT&T cellular service.
Medical Alert does require a service agreement. They also have a 30-day money back guarantee.
Bay Alarm offers a lifetime warranty on all of their equipment. They do not require any type of contractual obligation or service agreement.
Medical Alert's In-Home with a Landline monthly and semi-annual plan costs approximately $20. The cost for the annual plan is $19 per month. The cellular plan, also known as the In-Home without a Landline runs $30 per month, $28 semi-annually, and $26 per month for the annual plan.
Bay Alarm costs are paid on a monthly, quarterly, or semi-annual basis. The In-Home Medical Alert starts at $20 per month/$60 per quarter/$120 semi-annually. The Mobile GPS plan starts at $30 per month/$90 per quarter/$189 semi-annually. There are no charges for the equipment or installation. An extended service plan is available if the customer is interested. There is a $10 a month charge if the fall detection feature is chosen. There is an activation fee of $49.95.
Medical Alert's devices include a base unit with two-way communication, a wristband, and a pendant. Both the pendant and wristband are waterproof and extremely durable.
Bay Alarm Medical offers a base unit and a waterproof pendant. The pendant has a range of 1000 feet from the base unit. A mobile help button is also available if the customer wants coverage when they leave their home.
Both Medical Alert and Bay Alarm Medical offer self-installation. Each company offers easy to follow instructions for installation and set up.
Both Medical Alert and Bay Alarm Medical offer landline and cellular connectivity with support for over 150 languages each. Both companies are also well-known for almost immediate response times in connecting with the customer after an alert has been received. Once emergency personnel have been dispatched, family members will also be notified.
Summary: Medical Alert vs Bay Alarm Medical
Medical Alert is a good choice for individuals who want a choice of devices as well as connection options. The emergency connectivity is reliable and the devices are durable.
Bay Alarm Medical is an affordable choice for someone who would prefer to have just the pendant. It can be worn in the shower and has a range of 1000 feet. The mobile Help button is available if needed.